What Are the Essentials of a Thorough Board Review Process?


What are the essentials of a thorough board review process

There are many different requirements for boards to conduct periodic evaluations and report their effectiveness, fostering accountability and transparency within organisations.

Australia’s ASX Corporate Governance Principles and Recommendations require that listed entities carry out a structured evaluation process. Meanwhile, the New York Stock Exchange mandates an annual self-assessment by the board, ensuring the board’s and its committee function well.

Knowing all this, a pivotal question arises: what does it mean for a board evaluation to be thorough, and conversely, what constitutes a lack of rigour? To delve into this intricate inquiry, a virtual round table discussion was organised in the second half of 2023, facilitated by Halex Consulting, our esteemed UK partner. The discussion gathered prominent figures in corporate governance, including Company Secretaries, Chairs, and Directors from diverse UK-based companies, including those listed on the stock exchange.


Insights from the round table discussion

In-depth evaluations necessitate a thorough introspection encompassing board dynamics, committee operations, and individual director performance. An evaluation process is considered rigorous when encompassing many parameters, leaving no aspect unexamined.

  • Engaging external experts can enhance the evaluation process. Independent facilitators bring objectivity and expertise, ensuring the assessment is conducted impartially, without any internal biases.
  • A quality evaluation is data-driven, relying on both qualitative and quantitative metrics. It involves the collection of feedback from stakeholders, analysis of financial performance, and a qualitative assessment of leadership qualities and decision-making abilities.
  • If there is a provision for constructive feedback, there are higher chances of identifying strengths and weaknesses. Boards can propose actionable recommendations for improvement, ensuring that the evaluation process catalyses positive change within the board and its committees.


Along with these points, it was found that irregular evaluations do not set the right culture of continual improvement. Regular assessments enable boards to adapt effectively to changing market dynamics and governance challenges.


Evolving board effectiveness reviews: Balancing depth and efficiency

The process of evaluating board effectiveness is not a one-size-fits-all endeavour. Recognising the nuanced nature of organisational dynamics, many companies adopt a strategic approach, incorporating in-depth reviews and lighter-touch evaluations into their governance framework.

Every second or third year, organisations critically examine their board’s performance, commonly known as a ‘deeper dive review.’ This multifaceted analysis delves into the intricacies of board operations, aiming for a nuanced understanding of its functioning.

The methodology involves:

Well-designed surveys and interviews
Directors and executives participate in thoughtfully crafted benchmarked board, committee and individual director surveys, allowing them to provide candid feedback. Additionally, one-on-one interviews with key stakeholders within and outside the board allow for deeper insights into individual and collective performance.

Document review and observational analysis
A review of critical documents, such as Charters, meeting agendas, information packs, and minutes, provides context to the board’s decision-making processes. Observing board and committee sessions offers invaluable real-time observations of how policies and strategies translate into practice.

Expert-driven analysis
Skilled experts distil the collected data into a comprehensive report, highlighting findings and recommendations. This expert-driven analysis ensures a nuanced understanding of the board’s strengths and areas for improvement, often serving as a roadmap for future governance strategies.


Lighter touch reviews can streamline evaluation

In the intervening years, a ‘lighter touch review‘ provides a more streamlined evaluation process, acknowledging the need for periodic assessments without overwhelming the board with extensive scrutiny.

This approach maintains momentum in the board’s quest for excellence and employs the following techniques:

Comprehensive surveys
A well-structured benchmarked board survey, either a condensed version of the deeper dive review or an identical survey, is administered to directors and executives. While more concise, this survey still captures essential feedback, ensuring that critical aspects of board performance are assessed regularly.

Outsourced expertise
While many lighter-touch reviews were traditionally handled internally, outsourcing these assessments to external parties is an emerging trend. These experts bring objectivity and industry benchmarks, enhancing the reliability of the evaluation process. Using a well-researched survey coupled with benchmarked reports adds depth to the review.

Clear feedback and actionable insights
External parties often deliver an Executive Summary to the board, presenting the key findings and recommendations. Subsequently, the Chair and the entire board receive a detailed debrief, ensuring that the insights are transparent and actionable. This clear feedback loop is essential for informed decision-making and continuous improvement.


What is the best process to ensure a thorough board assessment?

The dual approach of alternating between deep-dive evaluations and lighter-touch reviews strikes a delicate balance. It allows boards to continuously focus on improvement without overwhelming directors with annual exhaustive assessments. By integrating the expertise of external parties, boards gain access to industry best practices, ensuring that their governance processes remain adaptive and effective in the face of evolving challenges.

This nuanced approach to board effectiveness reviews empowers organisations to uphold the highest leadership standards, transparency, and accountability, ultimately steering them towards sustained success in the global marketplace.


Actionable insights benchmarked with comparable boards in your industry

Board Surveys pioneers a groundbreaking approach by offering Lite and Essentials board surveys without the constraints of lock-in contracts. This unique proposition empowers organisations with the flexibility to choose assessment options that align seamlessly with their needs and budgetary constraints.

This flexibility is invaluable, allowing boards to adapt their evaluation strategies as the governance landscape transforms without being tied down by long-term commitments.

Board Surveys changes the landscape of board evaluations. We grant boards the autonomy to tailor their evaluation strategy, ensuring it aligns precisely with their unique needs and objectives. With affordability, self-management, and access to a world-class framework and benchmarking, boards can embark on their governance improvement journey with confidence and financial prudence.

Try a FREE 4-minute survey and receive a benchmark report today to see how Board Surveys can help with your evaluation process.


Benchmarking Board Performance

Gain actionable insights that are benchmarked with comparable boards within your chosen industry

Want to try a Board Effectiveness Survey?

Try a free 3 minute board effectiveness sample survey and get a benchmarked performance report

Stay up to date with our Insights & Ideas

"*" indicates required fields

A female asking team if their board survey benchmarked
Try our FREE Board Effectiveness survey
and receive a
benchmarked report